* 4× Grey Cup champion
* 10× CFL All-Star
* 10× CFL East All-Star
* CFL's Most Outstanding Player Award
* 2× Jeff Russel Memorial Trophy
* Tiger-Cats' Best-of-the-Century Team
* University of Guelph Athletics Hall of Fame
* Ontario Sports Hall of Fame
* South Dakota Sports Hall of Fame
* South Dakota Hall of Fame (en)