Pseudoscientific language comparison is a form of pseudoscience that has the objective of establishing historical associations between languages by naive postulations of similarities between them. While comparative linguistics also studies the historical relationships of languages, linguistic comparisons are considered pseudoscientific by linguists when they are not based on the established practices of comparative linguistics, or on the more general principles of the scientific method.

PropertyValue
dbpprop:abstract
  • Pseudoscientific language comparison is a form of pseudoscience that has the objective of establishing historical associations between languages by naive postulations of similarities between them. While comparative linguistics also studies the historical relationships of languages, linguistic comparisons are considered pseudoscientific by linguists when they are not based on the established practices of comparative linguistics, or on the more general principles of the scientific method. Pseudoscientific language comparison is usually performed by persons with little or no specialization in the field of comparative linguistics. It is the most widespread type of linguistic pseudoscience (another example being pseudo-etymology). The most common method applied in pseudoscientific language comparisons is to search two or more languages for words that seem similar in their sound and meaning. While similarities of this kind often seem convincing to laypersons, linguistic scientists consider this kind of comparison to be unreliable for two primary reasons. First, the method applied is not well-defined: the criterion of similarity is subjective and thus not subject to verification or falsification, which is contrary to the principles of the scientific method. Second, the large size of all languages' vocabulary makes it easy to find coincidentally similar words between languages. Because of its unreliability, the method of searching for isolated similarities is rejected by nearly all comparative linguists (however, see mass lexical comparison for a very controversial method that operates by similarity). Instead of noting isolated similarities, comparative linguists use a technique called the comparative method to search for regular (i.e. recurring) correspondences between the languages’ phonology, grammar and core vocabulary in order to test hypotheses of relatedness. Certain types of languages seem to attract much more attention in pseudoscientific comparisons than others. These include languages of ancient civilizations such as Egyptian, Etruscan or Sumerian; language isolates or near-isolates such as Basque, Japanese and Ainu; and languages that are unrelated to their geographical neighbors such as Hungarian.
  • Az áltudományos nyelv-összehasonlítás az áltudományok egyike, amely történeti kapcsolatokat kíván állítani különféle nyelvek között azáltal, hogy a közöttük lévő hasonlóságokra hívja fel a figyelmet. Amíg az összehasonlító nyelvészet a nyelvek történelmi kapcsolatait is figyelembe veszi, a nyelvészek azokat a nyelvészeti összehasonlításokat, amelyek a nyelvészet és a tudományos munka általános szabályait figyelmen kívül hagyják, áltudományosnak minősítik.
  • 偽言語比較論（にせげんごひかくろん）は、合理的あるいは科学的な方法によらずに牽強付会で言語の系統を論ずるものをいう。疑似科学、トンデモ研究の一種。エジプト語、エトルリア語、シュメール語などの古語や近隣に同系の言語が見当たらないバスク語やアイヌ語などが取り上げられやすい。
dbpprop:hasPhotoCollection
dbpprop:reference
rdfs:comment
  • Pseudoscientific language comparison is a form of pseudoscience that has the objective of establishing historical associations between languages by naive postulations of similarities between them. While comparative linguistics also studies the historical relationships of languages, linguistic comparisons are considered pseudoscientific by linguists when they are not based on the established practices of comparative linguistics, or on the more general principles of the scientific method.
  • Az áltudományos nyelv-összehasonlítás az áltudományok egyike, amely történeti kapcsolatokat kíván állítani különféle nyelvek között azáltal, hogy a közöttük lévő hasonlóságokra hívja fel a figyelmet.
  • 偽言語比較論（にせげんごひかくろん）は、合理的あるいは科学的な方法によらずに牽強付会で言語の系統を論ずるものをいう。疑似科学、トンデモ研究の一種。エジプト語、エトルリア語、シュメール語などの古語や近隣に同系の言語が見当たらないバスク語やアイヌ語などが取り上げられやすい。
rdfs:label
  • Pseudoscientific language comparison
  • Áltudományos nyelv-összehasonlítás
  • 偽言語比較論
owl:sameAs
skos:subject
foaf:page
is dbpprop:redirect of